I really enjoy your podcast. It’s nice to listen to a podcast in which the hosts don’t take themselves seriously. After, listening to your podcast, I watch episodes again, because your podcast identified scenes I missed in the episodes. Your podcast has made the show more interesting.

Listening to episode 1. So far so bad. These women are so annoying. They have no clue about the Franklin Expedition. Their comments are vacuous. The upspeak and vocal fry make it unlistenable. FAIL! Did you just grab some chicks of the street to do this? Get a couple of guys on the panel before it's too late. (Oh. it's too late. Just listen to a few later episode?) They did get a guy on the panel and they are all still boring. Do they even watch the show?

Love you guys ! Keep up the great work. I wish I could join the live chat but I work nights. Anyways 5 Stars !!! Great chemistry and found myself laughing along with you.

Please hire literate hosts with command of the English language. Conduct some research. Prepare your material. Know your audience.

Such insight! Such depth of thought! Such understanding of the subject matter! Just kidding. Predicting that there will be cannibalism? Do they even know that this is based on a true story? The level of ignorance and vapidity is astounding.

For such a hotly anticipated new series, this after show is a let down. The series is heavily male-centric, yet you have three female hosts who have zero connection. You should have at least two male hosts who can give us that perspective and insight into the storyline and the characters’ experiences, not these hosts who should probably be discussing something like Vanderpump Rules instead. Please do right by this amazing series and get some different hosts. (Also, the Maria Menunos podcast ad should be moved to the start of the show - it’s such a distraction in the middle of what should be a serious review and discussion.)