As they think they are. And too much cackling

Aa

Ok show not bad commentary! However, sometimes just wrong info. If you have a podcast in the show at least be accurate. Predictions on who goes home being Sandra? She has an idol that is only good for the next tribal so clearly will play it... how do all 3 miss that and pick her to go home? Also, wrong on other random facts. I get it’s hard to be perfect people will be wrong but there are multiple occasions where they miss info. Enough roasting though it is an ok podcast that I’ll only listen too if I run out of other survivor podcasts tbh. Love that you called this out 😂 I was way wrong better rating for you still leave my wrong comment up here. Thanks for handling my rudeness professionally!

I love Colleen and Jack but for the love of God please stop podcasting Jay. You’re clearly tired of podcasting especially about Survivor. Your irritation and lack of respect for your wife just makes this no fun anymore. No more listening and no more Patreon unless Jay leaves!

Seriously !!! Who does a podcast with a crying baby on their lap??

This is the show that tamed Colleen. It's much easier to appreciate her knowledge of Survivor when she's not trying to be the over the top or provocative like on the Tribe. They're family and have a nice chemistry that's easy to listen to and clearly they know what they're talking about.

Unscribed. Didn't listen for 15 minutes of latest podcast before I had to hear Colleen's opinion of Trump. Not a fan of him but I don't need to know what she thinks about Trump. Keep to Survivor.

Super funny and intelligent podcast!

Very fun and entertaining

You're right, Jack. I've made a huge mistake.

Great podcast. I love it. It's the only Survivor podcast I listen to consistently. But Jay really needs to work on that scoring system (and math). It's terrible. It's only fair in that everyone is equally dissatisfied with it. It doesn't make any sense. Each host might as well be pledging a certain number of delegates to each contestant because even that screwed up system makes more sense than this one. Also, I hate to admit it, but Colleen is always right. It's tough to write those words but it's impossible to deny. Facts.

Awesome dynamic between the podcast legends that are Jay and Jack. Add in Coleen, and it becomes a magical auditory experience.

Excellent podcast, everyone needs to lay off Jay's system! It really was fair. Colleen just thinks she is right about everything. Enjoy it!

Jay and Jack were my "go to’s” during the Lost days. So glad I stumbled upon this podcast recently and was thrilled they are talking about Survivor. And, bonus, Colleen too!

This is a great trio (and occasional guest hosts) of podcasters, and they are the perfect crew for the “water cooler” talk about Survivor. Been listening to them since the beginning, back in the Lost podcast days. Hard to believe it’s been over a decade. Now, on to their somewhat confusing point scoring. Guys (and Colleen) - This is how you should score points when you pick a new winner. Instead of getting points on how many weeks the castaway made it, as you do with your original pick, when you pick a new person, you mark the week you chose them, and then you only get points based on how many weeks you had them. This prevents someone picking at the final four and getting a ton of points.

Sometimes you just gotta find someone who shares your love of tv shows. Survivor is a classic and sure, it's been on forever but these guys make it so much more fun! Love the recaps, love their reactions, and love their predictions! Don't miss it!

I don't watch Survivor on a regular basis anymore, but I do listen to this show every week. Jay, Jack, and Colleen are great

I love this show because it's lighthearted and smart at the same time. Plus Colleen is hilarious. Actually Jay Jack and Colleen r all funny, but Colleen's laugh will win u over every time.

I literally died laughing when I heard the intro and loved the chemistry of the podcast. Hilarious and I will be subscribing 👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽

Good Survivor Podcast

I recently started listening to this podcast and became a fan from the first episode. Colleen, Jay, and Jack are WOONDERFUL and hilarious. They have great chemistry and the episodes are always a lot of fun!

Fun show! Great dynamics! I love how Colleen and Jack school Jay on Survivor knowledge. I listen to 5 survivor related podcasts a week and this one always makes the rotation.

I like how the host are clearly fans of Survivor but are not “Survivor Historians” and remember the exact boot order… It is just a really fun show and the host have great chemistry. Only disappointed husbands of disappointing housewives wouldn’t appreciate this show!

Jay, Jack and Colleen are all die hard Survivor fans. They break down the episodes and have fun speculating about moves being made and who will go home next. They do go off topic sometimes but it all adds to the fun.