On one hand, I generally enjoy their Bachelor commentary and some of the deserved snark against the show. However, they veer on judgy meanness and even a bit of misogyny in their commentary about women on the show sometimes. While I know this pod is described as a roast, they often mock people (other women) in an attempt to be funny and I mostly find myself cringing at how mean it comes off. This is despite describing themselves progressive and feminist.

Cecily and Stefanie bring infinite amounts of laughter and joy to my life on a weekly basis. They’re just both so smart, witty, funny, and hilarious beyond words to the point where we have “My Wife, The Car” references on a Bachelor final rose recap. They deserve all the praise for the hilarity they bring us all each week. I couldn’t go another week without putting some poorly worded, not nearly close to enough recognition into a review ❤️. Long story short, you are both the best Cecily and Stefanie 💜💜!!

Yes you are my favorite podcast !!

Love the Bachelor recaps but not the Real Housewives. They r so biased towards their favorites that they fail to see the other side. They are so mean to whoever is not their favorite.

Cecily is absolutely hilarious . She’s judgy but not in a mean way. It’s hard to explain but she has it figured out . Steph is funny but she comes off as judgy in a mean, too serious way . She takes it too far sometimes. You can tell even Cecily finds it off putting at times. Another review said stop saying macro note and I have to agree . Very pointless

You preach tolerance and acceptance and you have the nerve to put down the Mormon church --you are the worst kind of hypocrite --unsubscribed --quit listening to this evil hateful woman.

You make weird and mean assumptions about Zoe. Usually I can deal with your snark but your comments this episode and the next veered on the level of mean girls. That mafia stuff was inappropriate and unnecessary.

Last week they called Julianna a “Trumper” Not too many Trumpers out there with nose rings! Haha. Made fun of Dina’s looks. Tearing women down. Not so much Cecily doing this but Stephanie ( is that her name?) is the worst.

Edit to add: YES, pls recap Denise Richard’s show! You two do the best recaps ever. So happy you guys finally recapped the Valley-so good! The Brittany impersonation is the best Lol Edit—LOVE that you’re recapping the Golden Bachelorette and OC You two are hilarious EDIT—can you pls stop saying ‘Macro note’? So much? It feels like it’s said before every major thought and it makes no sense

Stephanie, please stop using the c word, it’s gross and offensive.

He IS enjoying his breakup with Joan. She never saw it coming. Very typical of men who like him are serial dating. The more she hurts, the more he gets a rush. Also they choose attractive women.

I love you both, but can you please stop saying “macro-note” just say it, thank you!

The banter between Stephanie and Cecily is fabulous! So funny and quite entertaining, thank you!!

That snake story was freaky!!

Love to escape into your podcasts which bring me joy. Especially when y’all go off on tangents and trips down memory lane to the 80s and 90s and Texas (Dallas lady here). Great banter about these silly shows that I can’t stop watching 🤪!

Soooo funny! Their improv is 100/100!! I love how their brains work!! I don’t get how they do it… just hysterical. Love them so much!

Omg I’m stunned at the hateful reviews it’s like are the reviews by bots or something?? Love these ladies, they always make me laugh and I enjoy all the different things they bring to the pod. Sending you love and support!!

I look forward to all of Stephanie and Cecily’s podcasts. Are they always super accurate? No and that’s not why I listen. Are they typical LA Liberals? Yes as are most podcasts based in LA. Get over it, they produce a lot of content and they’re both funny. If you want literal recaps of every second of a specific reality show those exist and aren’t entertaining.

This is the worse podcast ever .. bunch of mean girls !! Hateful rude moderator in group page. This went down hill when Ronnie left! Will never listen again! Stephanie HATING Trump fans is so sickening GROW UP!!

I love the RHOC recaps. Even more than watch what crappens.

I’m a fan of Stefanie, but I find she frequently spreads misinformation. Please check your facts before saying something that could harm someone’s reputation. Cecily makes me laugh nonstop. P.S.-please stop talking politics. I don’t think that’s why people tune in to the show.

Awful. Stef is the worst

Do these ladies know you don’t have to complain about everything?

Stephanie and Cecily are so funny that I don’t even have to watch the Bachelor shows. I just listen to them and laugh the whole time.

Is it supposed to be funny? Stef is an idiot

This podcast checks all my boxes. I’m here for the right reasons. You are my people! ( And it’s my first year in the bachelor world.)

I’ve been listening to Steph since she had this podcast with the guy from watch what crappens. Cecily is such an improvement. I will always love this podcast. They give the best opinions. If you love reality tv this is an amazing podcast to add. Forever a favorite.

They are a couple of mean girls who love to complain when there is nothing to complain about. They are neither funny or smart.

Stephanie is so negative on every single episode, it’s become impossible to listen to this podcast. I’m sorry for Cecile for being dragged down by Stephanie, but there are too many truly funny recaps of the Bachelor out there to waste time on this one.

Team Garcielle! Sorry Stephanie

The shrill of their annoying voices I freaking can’t take one more minute. Good grief chicks- GET A GRIP, you guys are beyond gross.

Listened to one episode and that’s one too many. How do women have these views on other women this day and age? Victim blaming? Cool. Must be part of that insane swath of old white women voting for Trump. So sad they have nothing else to do. Podcasting isn’t for everyone.

Tried to listen and had to stop very early in because I was getting upset.

I can’t listen because the facts are not right and the ladies are very rude.

Loved you two with Pat & Dylan!

Love the show, but you are wayyyyyyyy behind on Love is blind… we are 6 episodes in! They don’t give one a week, they gave us 6 to start, next week 3, etc. We will have seen 9 shows when you do a podcast of show 2. Can’t listen to shows this far back. Catch up, please.

Tbh they are so unaware of how the show is made that their takes are often just incorrect and end up being really rude. I liked this show for a while but it’s become hard to listen to. Overall, these women are ignorant and rude and try to pass it off as comedy. Not funny.

Girls! love the show but the ads are so bad and intrusive! They cut you off mid sentence - and the ads are the worst! Five stars still for an otherwise so so fun pod with great hosts!

Isn’t this a podcast about the bachelor? It is after all about roses being given out…Rosepricks? We would love a podcast about the original shows. Even if the cast is older

Horrible. The hosts don’t even have the basic facts of the Natalia Grace doc and just guess or gloss over details.

Why recap the show if you don’t watch it or don’t pay attention when you do watch it? I just can’t with all of the factual errors I keep hearing. Your commentaries are usually spot on but with this show it’s clear you couldn’t care less about talking intelligently about it. It’s super frustrating for the listener when you get even the most basic and even the major facts wrong. It’s very hard to listen to and is not funny. Further it damages your credibility as podcasters.

Hi! I want to start by saying that I enjoy listening to your Bachelor recaps and I’ve been listening for a few years at this point. I saw that y’all recapped The Curious Case of Natalia Grace, which I was excited about because that was a wild ride. However, I became frustrated with the amount of discrepancies between what really happened (or what the docuseries showed) vs y’all’s retelling of it. It got to a point where I just couldn’t listen anymore. It made me question if y’all even really paid attention or watched it. To give some examples for just part 2: they didn’t take her phone until the second apartment but shortly gave it back because CPS had started following them again. Then there was Jacob who went to Canada at 14 because a university asked him to attend in order to receive his masters and not a chess tournament?? Another one was Natalia was receiving food stamps and social security but the SS checks were going to Michael and he claimed he was using the money for her rent, bills, etc. the family that took her in used Natalia’s food stamp money and Natalia changed who received the SS check to that woman. I know there was a couple from part 1 as well. I’m not one to write reviews and I acknowledge this was unsolicited feedback. I want to keep listening to y’all because I agree with most of y’all’s opinions about things. Even if I don’t agree, I appreciate and consider differing perspectives. Moreover, I also want to hear accuracy.

I tried listening to a couple of the Natalia Grace episodes, but I couldn't stomach it. One of the podcast hosts had only watched one of the six episodes of the series while trying to talk about it. In the third episode, they had a bunch of facts wrong. For example, they were mixed up on whose lawyer was whose and also on what the expert was testifying about. Take notes and get your facts straight! Also, I don't find this podcast funny at all.

I loved your reference to Emily Kimberly (from the movie Tootsie) in this week’s podcast. That was so funny and so spot on! I laugh out loud to your Bachelor recaps. Keep them coming! I listen to a handful of Bachelor podcasts and this is the first one I look for every week. There’s an easy dialogue between you two and so, so funny!

It’s so sad, I used to love this show and laugh so much. Stepanie has become bitter and keeps bringing up politics. She can’t see anything going around her in the world and can’t fathom people having different opinions than her. For a group that spouts tolerance, she sure as heck can’t tolerate people with different views. So sad. Grow up.

I love the VPR episode recaps and your perspectives about it. Keep it up ladies! I hope you recap the reunion too. ♥️

Micah’s teeth remind me of Emily Maynard from the Bachelor. Is that who you’re thinking of?

I have given this pod several tries but I have a really hard time stomaching some comments made. They both come off stuck up and have zero empathy for the people they talk about it. Yea it’s realty tv but some of them go through real people problems.

Please have Ronnie & Ben on again and again!

Love the show ladies. Keep bringing it.