I was shocked to hear this, and very disappointed. I love the format of this podcast and it is very informative, but when I heard abt this case, I couldn’t listen to it anymore.

Google her and John Guica… she was found by an appellate court for misconduct in suppressing evidence. Wild.

Anatomy of Murder is simply the best true crime podcast out there. Full stop.

You guys are hating for no reason she is the professional who has been doing this for many years while your someone behind a screen who has to much time on your hands and feel the need to hate…. Anyway this podcast is gasssss I highly recommend!!!!

I was particularly interested in the fetal abduction case so I did some research and it turned out the perpetrator Lisa Montgomery was indeed sexually and physically abused and tortured her entire childhood and teenage years. The abuse and torture were so severe that I had reasons to be believe she was out touch of reality when she committed the crime. There was video evidence of her ex-husband whom she was fighting against for custody raping and beating her but the show only mentioned how Lisa Montgomery was lying about her infertility. It’s also bizarre and noteworthy that Lisa Montgomery was the only one who was executed for fetal abduction while the other perpetrators who had committed the same crime all escaped death penalty. The show really could have talked about this more. This show is very one-sided and only focuses on the heinousness of homicide but does nothing to actually explore why murders happen. Of course, there is nothing wrong with focusing on putting killers behind bars and praising law enforcement for their diligence but given the name of show “anatomy of murder”, the anatomy feels inadequate and incomplete. I would still follow the show though. It’s good and informing. But I encourage listeners to do research on their own to find more about the cases discussed by the show.

Anna how could you put winning a murder case, and putting a FACTUALLY INNOCENT TEENAGER imprisoned??? Just to be able to claim that “as a prosecutor, you never lost a case?” You pressured a teenage girl to make things so much harder for her dad that was in jail if that teenager girl did NOT get on the stand and testify to what YOU-Anna forced her to say!!! What about the other young man in jail that you forced to give absolutely FALSE testimony in the same trial, forced him to say exactly what you told him, about the factually innocent teenager making a “confession “ when in FACT it never happened. But in return, you dropped all his chargers, plus kept him out of other trouble/charges, just so you could win at any cost, ZERO care that the teenager was factually innocent, plus you dang well knew all of this. Then when you -Anna had to take the stand and testify on these events of what you forced the teenage female and the male that you got rid of all of his current charges plus others, you were NOT HONEST. I heard all of this on another true crime show, and was horrified, because as a prosecutor you are held to a higher duty. It’s not about winning at all cost to have a perfect record, it called the Justice system, where the scales are to be equally. You disgust me. You should never have a license to practice law at all. Every case you prosecuted should have a very deep review. America does NOT NEED OR WANT prosecutors such as you.

The episode doesn’t start till it hits 3 min mark. And except another 2x 3min ads before 30 mins.

Use to listen. Anna is a terrible person. She convicted an innocent kid. Watch the 20/20 episode everyone! This woman is disgusting.

Disappointing

Justice for Mark Fisher and Justice for John Giuca. I loved this podcast until recently. You claim to tell the victims stories but what about the man who wrongfully convicted to save you “winning” record. He is a victim of you Anna-Sigga. Shame on you.

Duboise

This show used to be one of my favs until I found out Anna is a fraud!

Anna needs to be cancelled..

use to be a fan till i found out host lied on a trail

I’m a longtime fan of the podcast. The hosts offer just the right blend of background, detail, and expert opinion. However, I just finished listening to a 20/20 True Crime Vault podcast episode on the conviction of John Giuca. Anna-Sigga, your credibility was an ADA was called into question. How or should this influence how I take in information you share on AoM?

After John Giuca, I can’t listen anymore.

How many people have you had wrongfully convicted for suppressing evidence? Hope you apologize to John Giuca

I have listened to every episode of AOM and the March 4th episode, Eerily Calm was so very powerful and bittersweet. At a time where there is so much darkness in the world this case was a full circle story. Well done ALL!

I have been listening to yall for quite sometime & couldn’t recommend your show enough! The hosts are informative, educational, and also caring to the victims & their cases.

Been listening since 2020 when y’all were introduced by Crime Junkie!! I love the fact y’all bring investigations and family members to tell the stories from their point of view, very impactful! True Crime Junkie ♥️

I liked this podcast until every other commercial was telling me To vaccinate my child or I’m not doing my job as a Mother. Not going to apologize for not poisoning my children. There is no place for political ads in true crime podcasts.

I enjoy both hosts. Great story telling. I’ve listened to everyone. Keep up the good work on sad topics

Nope. One narrator please and not the dude

This podcast used to be a favorite of mine, but has seriously gone downhill since becoming part of Audiochuck. True crime lovers do not care about your political opinions, agenda, or made up words! Ditch Ashley Flowers and get back to the way things used to be. The show was closer to 5 stars back then, now it’s 1 star and an unfollow!

The best True Crime Podcast there is!! 💗

I like this podcast, but here is a fact about a community that is harassed and abused and often ignored more than any other: it is intellectually disabled. You never hear about it because most go unreported because family and individuals are too traumatized to report this. This group of individuals is marginalized more and more. I just thought I would give you some insight into this issue.

Absolutely NOT. Unfollowed.✌️

I already really enjoyed this show, but their recent compassionate coverage of Nikki Kuhnhausen’s murder tipped me into loving it. This team is thorough, they aren’t here for “rubbernecking,” and they frankly and honestly talk about the contribution of discrimination and hate to violence. Really important in these times. Thank you.

Such a great podcast with wonderful hosts. Thank you for handling the recent episode of Nikki with such care and sharing LGBTQ and trans stories. 💙

I used to be the biggest fan of this show, but the recent episodes have lost me as a fan. Pushing your political agenda and beliefs is not what listeners want. We're here to listen to true crime and the justice that comes from it via the justice system. Please remove the political nonsense and tell the story.

This used to be my favorite Tuesday podcast, but anymore it's more ads than episode. A very sad change.

This is the best crime show out there !

I started listening to these podcasts 3 days ago… I’ve now listened to 21 of them. I love being able to put my AirPods in and do the laundry while listening. It’s not detracting like TV is. My only issue is that I’m a little hyper vigilant while running now.😂😅

AOM is the best. I’m enthralled with every episode and I love Anna-Sigga’s style of vernacular as she educates and entertains me every week. I quote Scott in conversations. Guess I like them both so don’t stop bringing us the best shows on audiochuck

This is and has been my favorite true crime podcast- and I listen to a LOT. Not only do they have a vast knowledge of their respective fields, but they also can expertly explain it all to the laymen so we understand. Love you guys, don’t ever change!

I know they’re both in law enforcement but good grief they tie themselves in pretzels to absolve any lazy or corrupt cop in any story.

Will always listen to this — one of the best true crime podcasts!

Anna-Sigga Nicolazzi concealed evidence in 2 separate murder trials during her time as a prosecutor. Her presence on this podcast destroys any and all credibility. I’m disgusted that audiochuck continues to platform her.

Definitely a favorite and look forward to listening each week. Sometimes the editing is messed up and the same clips will be spliced back to back which is always kind of a funny catch. Today’s episode also called infamous serial killer Edmund Kemper “Edward” Kemper which was surprising. Other than the couple of editing/naming errors I’ve caught, I have no complaints other than I wish there was more than one episode a week!

Ugh, love the show but the background music for the latest episode is distracting and not good. It doesn’t help or punch up the quality of the detective’s monotone or bad sound quality of his speaking. For the most part, the background music is fairly unobtrusive but not today. I can’t …

“”There WAS enough important details “ should have bey there WERE”. Also see “had went” vs “had gone” Scott! Go back to 4th grade.

At the Mollie Tibbets case. Being angry about illegal immigration is not racist. It doesn’t matter where they come from, they shouldn’t be here. Mollie would still be alive.

I can’t listen to any others right now, I love this one!

i've been listening for a while but ...you are the first podcast I've heard covering my good family friend, and her tragic murder, AND spelled and pronounced her name correctly. Scott and Anna-Sigga: thank you for the kind and accurate description of Telma's brilliant smile. my mom entrusted me to her care on beaches, wherever, from the time I was very very young and I grew up with her in my mom's close circle of lady friends. I remember when she was carrying her daughter. Separately I grew up with the Emery family. What happened was devastating to our entire community but I really wanted to go out of my way to thank you for the way you covered that.

You can immediately tell the host telling these stories care about the victims! One of my favorite podcast!

Very thoughtful and love the voices. They are soothing but not boring.

I would encourage everyone to Google the name John Guica before you support this show. It’s a hard no for me.

I love this podcast. Very direct and focused on victims more than criminals.

Scott & Anna-Sigga are the best presenters. The show is so well done & so “easy” to listen to. One episode a week isn’t enough!!!

100% Love the presentation these two cover the subjects !!!