I only listen for the Reddit stories but there are often times I need to shut it off because the hosts are unbearable. Especially John. FYI guys, you’re not going to hit a million followers if you alienate half of the country. Take a page out of Smosh’s book and don’t talk about politics. We can assume the way Smosh leans but they don’t shove it in our faces. It’s very distracting the amount of times Josh says “uhhhhh” and “umm” if you are going to have a podcast you should try to speak a bit more eloquently. The amount of filler words is unnecessary.

writing this just to make the obvious trumpies in your reviews mad. I love that you guys are a safe space for everyone and are aware of the current political climate (essentially if you dont laugh, youll cry) and instead of ignoring it for the sake of a larger fan base, you make it clear where you stand and what will not be tolerated, and i love it. Keep it up

I used to love this Reddit and even paid for the patreon but now they are always talking about political stuff and ruined the podcast. I just wanted to listen to Reddit stories and have a break from all the world nonsense. So I stopped my patreon and unfollowed the show. No thanks

I love this podcast! The last few months have been too much for my mental health, so I’ve been listening to this podcast the most! John, Sean (spelling it properly. I know what it’s like, because very rarely do people know how to say my last name. 🤣) and Josh are amazing young men! You three along with my three sons, brothers and dad give me hope that good men exist still. That you support good people who are good to others. I love John’s sense of humor! I love Sean’s chill vibe. I love Josh’s calming voice. You give great pov’s and advice. Thanks for making me laugh and not lose the little bit of peace I still try to hold on to in this crazy world.

Just had to write this review to combat the trumpies that don’t like your political views. Obviously if you’re a dumb conservative don’t listen to these guys who clearly are compassionate guys trying to make the world a little better. Love you guys and love the work you do. And for the guy saying they just always side with the women, maybe it’s because the men are consistently wrong. Funny how that works.

You all are so funny and to be honest give me hope as healthy examples of masculinity in a world gone crazy. Thank you for your humor and your witty takes. Keep it going!! We need more humor these days

Thanks for being entertaining and open minded. Y’all are comforting to listen to, especially with the daunting upcoming four years. Keep it up!

How can you judge ANYONE when you “talk” to women using the phrase “baby girl”?

I’ve been listening for a bit now y’all are great but I’m like over 100 episodes down and a takes a hot second to scroll all the way down.

I use to love this podcast and think that they were so funny but it’s sad that they talk about politics so much and please educate yourself before you speak and not from TikTok or social media.

Best Reddit pod! Period! Their takes are down to earth and they don’t reach for crazy ideas without there being a solid reason for it.

I (34F) had made a Reddit account years ago, but didn’t start using the app until last year when I needed some highly specific work advice. A friend recommended asking the appropriate highly specialized subreddit, and I did so. (Got some great advice! Stopped my panic attack in its tracks.) Since then, I started browsing more, and stumbled upon this podcast by way of the subreddit. I decided to give it a listen, as I liked the idea of having other people curate the best Reddit posts for me. The first episode I listened to included a story I had seen about an OP whose sister cut off her and her husband when her husband made a highly political “joke” that was actually a threat against OP’s sister. I’ll admit, my first thought was, “Oh no! This show is hosted by three dudes. No way they’re going to side with OP’s sister.” That’s when S, J, and J put me in my place. Their outrage towards OP and empathy for the sister forced me to confront my own preconceived sexist notions. I had to admit that I’d been wrong to jump to the conclusion that they would side with the “dude” in any given scenario. Every episode I listen to goes further to prove how empathetic, witty, intelligent, and open-minded these three guys are. It’s such a breath of fresh air in today’s (American) political climate. I didn’t know “people read Reddit” was a podcast genre, but I don’t see myself ever needing another show in that subcategory besides this one. S, J, and J offer incisive commentary, mixed with plenty of laughs. I also seriously appreciate that they don’t waste time trying to adjudicate whether the post is real or made up. It’s more fun that they react to everything as if it’s 100% real! Their reactions are hilarious (especially when Sean hears about a relationship with a sketchy age gap), and I appreciate the thoughtful discussions that ensue. So AITA for liking this show? Nah, NTA.

I found yall on TikTok after I was hooked on other Reddit reading podcasts. Yall are my second favorite!! John is my favorite!!! I love y’all’s takes and I appreciate y’all’s point of view even if I’ve heard the story from other podcasts. I’ve gone back and listened to all of them (yay OCD)!! Keep up the great content!! I’ll be a Patreon soon!!!

I really enjoy this podcast. I listen to it often. However I find myself fast forwarding quite a bit on a select few episodes. Sometimes the laughter makes it hard to listen to. It’s not a little laughter here and there but actual laughing fits where you can’t hear the content at all. So my only suggestion is to trim down those parts. I think it’s a great show and will continue to listen just some positive feedback that would make it even better.

Entertaining while also being a refreshing beacon of light in this questionable world. Keep doing what you do.

Is it just me or is the editing not good in the latest episode? Otherwise I love listening to Reddit stories and these guys have quickly become a favorite group of mine

One of my top two favorite podcasts! Yall make me laugh so hard and it makes my long trip to and from work so much more enjoyable!

As stated in the description, I have enjoyed the show other than the more frequent use of “GD”. I don’t usually mind profanity, with the exception of “GD”. I’ve noticed you guys using it more frequently, lately. Just my opinion.

One of the best podcasts there is! I listen to it everyday at work and it really helps get through the day when your day starts at 2:30 AM. Yall are great keep on keeping on!

Had to stop and unfollow after the last episode. Good riddance boys✌🏽

I understand everyone has their political of view and a comment may come up now and then, but the constant put down of conservatives gets very old. I wanted a new Reddit series but now after several comments it’s just too annoying. I’m not even a conservative, however, this isn’t the place to discuss in my opinion

I came across this show during one of the toughest and most vulnerable times in my life, and while I’m still working through it, this show has made a huge difference. It’s brought me hope and entertainment I didn’t even know I needed. Each host has a unique personality and perspective, but they all share a strong sense of decency and morality. It’s been both refreshing and eye-opening to learn so much about relationships, humanity, and making sound judgments from just one podcast.

I’d give a million stars if I could. Absolutely love these humans. I will always recommend over any other Reddit based podcast. Thank you for being amazing humans John, Josh & Sean ❤️

Recently discovered this podcast and absolutely love it! I’m having so much fun listening to the new episodes and working my way through the backlog. Sean (as an Irish descendant this is the only true spelling!), John, and Josh have the loveliest camaraderie. I love their perspectives and how their points of view are so diverse, yet they’re constantly supporting and hyping one another up. This podcast is a great escape from the real world for me, and I love how it’s so positive even when covering the craziest stories. The hosts have cultivated an amazing community and they’re so inclusive and open to learning. Highly recommend! Can’t wait to keep listening!

Trying to hard all the time to not blame folks for they mistakes and what we listening to a white man about problems

Long time listener but find myself struggling lately. The amount of times Josh says like when speaking is distracting. Makes it hard to get through the episode. Sadly an unsubscribe for me as the show doesn’t feel the same lately.

I absolutely love this podcast! I can’t remember when I found them but I’m pretty much addicted! I listen to it almost daily with my dog (Rip Biskit💕) and my cat, Toby! The hosts are amazing and hilarious! I feel like the advice they give is good and they’re always super respectful with more sensitive topics which is awesome to see. I used to listen to a few other podcasts but this one is easily my favorite. (Btw if y’all see this Ty for all the laughs and for making my evenings a little more fun!)

I really enjoy this show, they are really funny and make my day better by listening. My only thing is that when they talk about politics or religion, I have to skip because it can be offensive. Doesn’t really matter though because they never read 4 star reviews 🤣

What’s up motherf*****s I’m officially a rich rich!! I can’t figure out how to work Patreon yet, so my review is going on here. I usually don’t even enjoy podcasts with men as the hosts, but these guys are so great! This podcast actually means so much to me. I struggle with severe anxiety and if I’m having an episode, I put on this podcast and it gets me out of my head and I’m able to be normal(ish) again after a while. I love this pod so much that even my dog listens when I go to work. 10/10 would recommend. I would have joined Patreon a while ago, but I wanted to finish all the other episodes first. I’m glad I can finally give back to you all as you have poured hours into my life unknowingly. Thank you for the time you have put into this. Random thoughts: The format of the pod is way better now from previous episodes Wednesdate for Wednesday updates #OgthaForever #KeepTheGoatNoise Absolutely loved the switch up from Josh doing the AITA Friday. (Not that there’s anything wrong with Josh) It was just funny to hear from the other side. You 3 are the best. I believe in speaking life so here ya go… I believe you can all quit your jobs one day and do this full time. Much love.

I just joined the patreon due to their support of the people of Palestine. I believe in supporting content creators who represent good and bring me hope in humanity

I literally switched to iPhone JUST to be able to rate my favorite podcasts on here. I have been following on YouTube for a long time now and have watched every episode on YouTube. As an older woman who was raised in a very different time, you ALL are a breath of fresh air. The empathy, compassion, emotional intelligence and maturity you all show, combined with amazing senses of humor, makes me hopeful for the future generations. I realize some may say it’s just a podcast and not that deep; however if young people can listen to the example y’all are setting, there is hope. ✌🏽

I barely listened to my first episode. One of these simps was talking about black rifle company coffee. Once he went in, I knew the simps (sad excuses to be called men) were complete liberal trash. They laugh at everything that isn’t funny and try so hard to be funny. I can tell why I have never heard of this podcast

While I generally enjoy this podcast and have been listening for a couple years now, I have to say that I'm kind of over John. There's not a single episode that he's on where we don't hear about how horny he is, how much p0rn he watches, how often he self-pleasures, how small he is, etc. and it's annoying. To be clear, there is absolutely no shame in being sex positive or hyper sexual, but it doesn't need to come up in EVERY joke, tangent, convo, episode, etc.. At this point I genuinely feel like I'm listening to a conversation between two adults (Josh and Sean) and a 12-year-old boy that just took his first sex-Ed class.

I can’t even get through the first episode. These guys are rambling on and on and on about the name topics that I would expect from a 12-year-old boy.

Great podcast! Love the hosts. I have been listening for several months now and look forward to new episodes every week. These guys are so funny and genuinely seem like great people. This podcast has helped me get through some hard days navigating postpartum depression/anxiety and long 12hr shifts at work. The commentary on the episode where the guy threw a steak at his wife’s bosses window when they were invited to dinner had me locked in forever haha. Appreciate the laughs. When my life is together I can’t wait to be a rich rich and support further. Again, thanks for the laughs!

It’s pretty slow at work today and y'all didn’t disappoint as usual. When I laugh till I cry it’s a good day for me. Unfortunately I was born beautiful and not rich but as soon as I hit it big, I got yall!!

I love the show. Their takes are different and hilarious. But I can’t stand the additional segments at the end from Underbakke. I don’t know why they keep trying these but they’re really not my favorite.

So don’t be afraid it is only men but they are good guys! Love hearing their takes. They are always fair and not sexist. Also don’t start with a live episode. I did that and was like naw this isn’t for me, but then I needed something to listen to so I started on a different episode and that was awesome! Love them! Also now that I know them better and the context live episodes are also great! Check them out!

Hey guys! I’ve been listening for almost a year now. I started last summer because I’d have to drive 3 hours from my hometown to go to grad school in Arizona for 2 months so you filled the time in the car on that drive and when I was by myself in the new city for 2 months. I’ve kept up and I love listening to you all (y’all) and I’m always literally laughing out loud in my car. My Reddit handle is Foxwithapoppy. You read my reposts on two occasions and I’m thrilled to have contributed. I also have a disaster date buried somewhere on your subreddit, but maybe you’re saving that for Sienna. I don’t know 😊 I’m also a proud Patreon member💗 Thanks for all that you do💗

I love this pod and it’s on my weekly rotation. I’ve binged most of the older episodes and now I wait patiently for each new episode to come out. These guys are so funny and genuine! I love their takes and sense of humor. Shout out Sean for reading the stories in such an entertaining way, I like his inflections lol

I’ve been teetering back and forth on this one but this last ep kind of solidified it for me. Just a bunch of weird loser dudes just hating on every dude in the story and giving the girls always a pass. Go listen to two hot takes or ok op if you want some good content that isn’t just bashing fellow losers

This has become my favorite podcast!! Love the advice and jokes y’all make!

I’ve been a listener for a long time. These guys are funny, relatable, and entertaining.

I’m someone who easily gets bored and it’s extremely hard for me to binge listen to a podcast. However, this podcast has caught my attention, and I’ve listened to almost every episode. Five Stars because I really enjoyed the podcast. BUTTTTT, One thing I absolutely cannot stand is when you guys discuss and comment on parenting. You’re very textbook biased when it comes to this topic and I can’t help but to tell myself “maybe when they have kids, they’ll finally understand. Until then, it’ll continue to be frustrating to listen to them particular stories.

Everytime I hear about Ogtha, I can’t help but think about the South Park episode about the lice. And then I want to throw up:)

…so all I’m going to say is these guys are the real aholes.

This is honestly my favorite podcast. You guys are great and I'm so happy that the pod is gaining more traction , you guys deserve it 🥲. Keep up the good work, love y’all <3.

I’ve been listening for about 6 months and have been loving it. Now that my only complaint has been resolved I’m here to leave a five star review. I just listened to the first episode of the year and finally the them song isn’t overstimulating. You did a great job! It’s refreshing listening to men whose takes I usually can get on board with. Y'all give me hope for the future. I’ve seen you grow and learn through this podcast. Your humility is inspiring. Thank you and looking forward to another year with you!

I periodically listen to this show and would definitely be a regular if you guys did updates on the stories. If there are updates from OP, I’d love to hear them. If closure is possible from these crazy stories, I’d love to know!

I only listen on podcasts, so I had to review to tell John..I mean.. GINE & Juliette that “Masta” was the name of my betta fish too!!!! I’m sure I thought I was so clever and funny for the name, but now I’m wondering how many others have had the same thought. lol. Anyways, although I listen to many podcasts you guys are definitely in my top 3! Thank you for the great content!