I’ve been listening for years, but I’m a centrist and these guys are super progressive who don’t know what cog dis is, smh. “Trump took kids away from their parents at the border!” So did Obama… and Biden kicked more illegal immigrants out of the country than Trump ever did. No comment other than what Trump did though. Cog dis shouldn’t include minimizing what the President that belongs to the party they belong to does, OR… maximizing something that the other side does that their own people also do. But… it’s hard to not have cognitive dissonance unless you’re neutral… which they absolutely aren’t. Edit- I’m still listening to it years later and they’re still the same, but I’m updating my review. Like… legitimately, I’m listening to how they should think… but they won’t because they’re Progressive. They literally contradict themselves. I listen to them doing it every week. 🤦🏻‍♂️

Another offset for truly offensive review called “Audible Mental Illness” ಠ_ಠ

Another review said, “Truly the craziest people I’ve ever listened to. Deranged and deeply resentful. Completely out of touch with reality.” That review was meant to be left for their local church but they accidentally left it on this podcast. Here’s my 5 star review to offset that.

This episode is one of the two or three best podsodes I’ve ever listened to. From anybody. Great show all over, but today was standout.

Truly the craziest people I’ve ever listened to. Deranged and deeply resentful. Completely out of touch with reality.

I was very very pleased to hear about you guys lightning it up. I’m one of the ones that has turned off all news and unsubscribed to many podcasts. I’m very thankful I’ll still have you boys (forgive me I’m 67) to make me smile and feel some see the world as I do. Been listening to y’all for about 5/6 years and have always enjoyed your show. The Donut Lady

You give me a way to speak to my notsoeloquent coworkers

Organize. (Or not) Resist & Assist resist! Take every page from the maga playbook and hand it back to them. Project 2025? Lady Liberty Project 2025. Million man March? Let’s do 5 million. Guerilla time!

Big fan of the show since 2011. Wanted to let you know that your most recent Thursday show was precluded by a “buy gold” advertisement. Keep fighting the good fight.

These hosts suffer from the very name of the show.With the amount of information available it is comical they don’t use any.

This is the cumination of the GOPs 50 year plan begun in 1975. But I was treated as an odd because I called them on their fascism ever since then. With Drumpf they began shouting the quiet part out loud.

I’m in the middle of a conservative state and your show helps keep me sane. I love your outrage and sense of humor about it all. Keep up the good work!

Well fellas, I suggest looking into the complications and side effects of vasectomies, and realize that promoting “meat-less” veganism is legit propaganda. This podcast is as bad as a fundamentalist Christian commentators like Allie B.

I’m reading these reviews and some are hilarious!! “oh… you go too far,…”whine!” Not far enough. We are not all the same. Nor do we treat each other fairly. We have these “pseudo-suit,” fake liberals that want “fair and balanced.” The truth isn’t fair to the mind of a magical thinker. You guys are fresh air in a polluted hellscape. Midwesterners don’t play! You make me proud to be one. Go get ‘em!!

I have listened to this for a long time (I think 5 years) and only missed a few episodes. I am left leaning and always have been but how far they have went is just too much for me. I agree with some things but find myself so far from what they are talking about now. (Very progressive) which I still would listen to in order to get all view points. But I feel like they just scream and say everyone that thinks differently or has different opinions is a horrible person. I think both sides have gone way too far and feels like everyone has lost their minds. I wish people would actually listen to each other and try and fully understand other perspectives. Wish them the best just can’t handle the negativity anymore.

Great, tender & genuine conversations between two besties

I listened for a while. It’s sometimes funny but the hosts have little real world knowledge while presenting themselves as wise know it alls. I’d pass and find a more interesting podcast if I was you.

I love these guys. They are great at pointing out the hypocrisy out there.

Hilarious prognostications on Trump looking back! I shared the exact astonishment as I watched it unfold. Glory hole!

A great show with intelligent and funny hosts.

Loved listening to you guys up until your last show, #737. Don’t put people down that live in vans. I live in a van. You don’t know what people’s situations are as to why they have chosen that lifestyle. To be so dismissive and judgmental turned me off so much that I am unfollowing. I won’t waste my time on people that assume the worst just because they don’t ‘approve’ of someone’s lifestyle. Just thought you should know.

Except not, the raw visceral hatred in that man's voice is something ill never forget from the daily car rides with my dad growing up. Glad he's gone

What’s up with the World Vision ads? Trigger warning for those who have ever been aurally raped at a CCM concert.

Been listening since about episode 50 or so. Tom and Cecil have changed over the years. They've become more compassionate and entertaining. They are willing to admit when they make a mistake. Which is an important attribute. Also, I love Ian McKellen. Those Adam and Eve ads were on point.

Their jokes are generally funny, the segments are informative at times, and their fundraising efforts are very noble, but their Liberal reactionary tendencies (lukewarm center-left) and extreme TDS will leave you rolling your eyes at the cognitive dissonance required to maintain such unserious, Blue MAGA stances, and reaching for the “Advance 30sec” button.

I wish podcasts would have disclaimers if they are politically biased or don’t at least have different perspectives. I tried but this podcast is little more than leftist drivel.

These guys are the best!

This is a great show. I read some of the one star reviews and they’re funny. They’re clearly from people who never listened to the show. Political, anti-religious… good stuff.

This show needs to be recategorized from religion to politics cause that’s all it is anymore. I was an avid listener from 2011 up until just a couple years ago. I listened to most of the whole Puzzle in a Thunderstorm lineup for a solid decade until pretty much all the shows abandoned humorous discussions related to religion and skepticism in favor of woke ranting and insulting anyone who doesn’t think exactly like they do. I guess if you enjoy far-left diatribes, hurling insults anyone who believes in any sort of afterlife or spirituality, smug virtue-signaling, wishing death on those you disagree with, and mocking republicans, then this is the show for you. But for actual independent thinkers, there is no relevant content here anymore. The hosts have a case of TDS worthy of its own wikipedia page, I imagine flying spittle coating their mics as they rage over the fact that there are people out there who don’t vote blue no matter who. Absolutely narrow-minded, hate-filled, and juvenile. Grow up and stop consuming yourselves with anger before you give yourselves strokes.

These guys research thought-provoking articles and then have interesting, challenging, often angry discussions about them and it totally works. Cecil says “period” way too much, which is an unattractive quality in any discourse, but since Tom always agrees with him it doesn’t come off as bad as it would it an actual debate. This podcast is very well-suited for “progressive but not Lincoln-hating crazy” dems, but if you’re looking for perspectives on both sides, it’s not for you. I would prefer if they gave some openness to the existence of a higher power but it’s not a dealbreaker. It’s the podcast you wish your right-wing dbag uncle would listen to and actually consider but that will never happen.

All of the content is at least 2–4 weeks old, and the hosts seem to have embraced this. I used to be a regular listener… Why would I keep listening for stories I’ve already heard? Tom and Cecil: I listen for interesting atheist–related news. Without the news, you are not interesting enough.

I love this podcast and I still agree with Eli Bosnick when he was on the show! Episode number 555 Fake Phone Number 👻 Episode 700 Atheist 700Club!

The topics are fine and your opinions are great, but it gets tiring listening to people screaming into a microphone. Stop yelling.

Tom is my favorite

I enjoy listening to these guys and agree with them on almost everything. However, they disappointed me with their lack of skepticism and questioning in the later phase of Covid-19. They and other skeptics became MAGA Blue or sounded like religious authoritarians and demonized anyone that asked questions. Their stance on take the shot and ask no questions because science says so was echoed by many as they ignored or drowned out the traditional scientific method. Because these guys and some other of my favorite skeptics REFUSED to ask questions regarding Covid-19 I was temporarily forced to stomach and listen in on shows like Ben Shapiro, Fox News, The McCullough Report, etc. All of whom I disagree with 99% of the time. But at least they were asking questions about Covid and talking to doctors that questioned the vaccine and had alternative treatment methods.

These two were my introduction to the modern day skeptic podcastosphere, couldn’t ask for two more insanely well-educated, worldly, and intelligent yet unpretentious men to start with. Providing insightful takes back to back with unrelenting humor. And of course, a shout out must be made to Ian’s ad skits! Love it!

I’ve been a listener for over 10 years and I don’t plan on stopping!

Even though they aren’t religious they definitely have their own dogma.

Honestly these guys are hilarious. They really explain how they feel on subjects and laugh at the absurdity of the outlying ideas on a political spectrum. My only problem is that there is no debate or attack on the other party for their flaws and outlying views. All hosts completely agree with one another and have no varying views. Claiming to think critically with skepticism on “any” topic that makes the news is really just a way for these guys to say “we’re telling our opinions on how the other party is wrong for this item… oh and we all agree with each other, so it’s all bad and just unthinkably stupid.”

Being skeptical only of things you believe aren’t true isn’t being a skeptic…

These people are morons. They are so blinded by the fact that republicans are evil that they cannot see that democrats are enabling the republican evil. They get so hurt by the truth that they insult anyone who tries to tell them, and then throws a hissy fit and claim people are calling them names. They are too stupid to realized they started the name calling. I will say the truth one more time but I doubt they got a brain cell left to listen. “Blue no matter who” is not a winning strategy and it is the reason why we lost roe v wade and vote shaming never works. You have to give people a reason to vote for your guy and “but trump” is not a reason.

I really love all your shows, but please stop fake laughing.

I’m a 41 year old wife and mother of an 8 year old and a two year old and I never thought I could personally have an abortion but was always pro-choice. I had an abortion last year. My husband wasn’t thrilled about it but was very supportive and said that it was completely my decision. This episode meant so much to me, and I just wanted to say thank you.

It’s just nonsense now, opened up the episode after row got turned down and it was just an entire episode about how awesome killing babies.

This podcast gives me hope that there are good people out there.

Keep up the great work guys!

I actually look forward to Mondays now. I love starting my week off with these guys. Great insights. Very funny.

We need another Ian and Gary song parody commercial.

It’s like sitting at a bar with friends talking about what’s going on. So much fun!

I love this show, would not miss an episode. Tom and Cecil make me laugh but they also make me think critically about the news.