I’ve come across a 1-star review that saddened me. The review consisted of a criticism of Isaiah, saying that the censorship of some words in some stories takes away from the original story. I believe that the person who created that review should become more open minded to the fact that some religions tell you, that you can’t curse. In conclusion, this 5-star review is to counteract the 1-star review, to raise the Apple podcast ratings.

Finally getting around to writing a review. Love this show. 10/10. Started because I love Isaiah. Now I love Hunter as well. Keep up the amazing work.

*crack* mroooooooooo

If anyone says it’s not a good podcast is lying out there teeth one of the best out there!

Shouts out to my juicy baby daddy meat and my baby momma with the juicy lips Wendi. I love u little homunculi. Genuinely one of the funniest , most interesting and at times frightening podcasts on the internet. Let’s hit number one again.

Love the show, but I didn’t see any reviews with two stars

Isaiah butchers stories by not reading them as the author wrote them. Certain words make him uncomfortable or he thinks it’s a sin to say them or something? I don’t know, but reading some of the stories how the author wrote them really made me feel like I’m missing out by listening to Isaiah read them to me. Will be looking for another scary stories podcast, the ‘no sleep podcast’ and the ‘magnus archives’ are good ones!

Binging all the episodes! Hunter and Isaiah are hysterical and I love their perspective on the stories they read.

I love this podcast. Wendigoon and Meat Canyon are a delightful pair together. Their personalities just bounce off of each other in a very entertaining way! Their stories are ( usually) amazing, very well written and the banter, reading and voice acting is a delicious cocktail of horror, entertainment and laugh out loud moments Not to mention they’ve gotten me into horror authors I had no idea existed so that’s great!

WHO UP CREEPING THEY CAST

This is a great podcast to listen to for extended commutes. Isiah and Hunter bring an excellent mix of humor and analysis to lesser known stories. I highly recommend this podcast, and I look forward to their weekly releases!

This is genuinely my favorite podcast to listen to. I try to listen to the new drops every Sunday and then I wish there were more! They are so funny together and the stories are sooo entertaining. Absolutely love it!

For a brief moment in 2024, this was the number one podcast in the world. It can be again.

hands down the best podcast i’ve ever listened to. it’s criminal that they’re not in the top 5

It’s wild how the biggest plot twist in the history of the show was “before getting out of bed that’s rough dude”.

The ads have gotten a bit much

I look forward to this podcast every week, it’s my favorite! Sometimes when there’s nothing good I just relisten to my favorites. Very wonderful r show!

u guys r the best ur podcast are so interesting

Seriously, this should be #1 on the charts.

Definitely did goon to this podcast.

Great mix of horror and humor.

Simply amazing. I listen to this for hours a day it’s so addicting!

Boy o boy, these guys crack me up. they’re my favorite duo after Rhett and Link. I listen or watch everyday while i’m getting ready and everyone has to hear about the newest creepypasta uploaded. I’ll be in class drawing pictures of jeff the killer or be reminded of kyle from a lecture, but I always think of papa meat and wendi first ❤️ but fr the literary analysis and vibes make my bad days good, thank you guys for your work!

One episode at a time. If I could give more than 5 stars I would happily do so.

I absolutely love listening to these while working. They make the day go by so much quicker

This is my emotional support podcast

Guys please make a tier list of all the stories you’ve read so far

Never thought I would fall in love with a podcast…… until about 3 months ago the rest is history tbh, it’s about all I watch/listen to now💛

I love this podcast!! It gets me through my work day. Isaiah and Hunter are so funny!!!!

Two beautiful men run this podcast

I love watching Hunter/Isaiah crashout while reading a terrible old creepypasta

It’s nice to see dad helping out the older creators on the platform.

Ever

i love isaiah and hunter, it really makes it awesome especially bc hunter can control fire

Long story short this is my favorite podcast ever whether it’s the well written stories or the goofy ones I love them all!

I love creepcast like hunter's grandpa loved their dog <3

Can’t name a better combo than Meat and Wendi

I drive for a living, I stay creeping my cast while I work 😮‍💨

Honestly, never cared for podcasts before this one. I also love creepy stories but can’t read them alone without spooking myself. When you listen to CreepCast, it’s like you’re just reading them with your best buds and while you’re getting well versed in the spooksphere, you’re having some great laughs. Who else is up creepin they cast?

This podcast does have it weird moments, but despite that it's honestly one of the best podcasts I've never listened to, and as silly as it probably sounds it has helped me through a few depressive episode I've had. I genuinely hope these two make it big and live good lives even with how strange the world has gotten lately

I love listening to their funny commentary and banters for some reason I can fall asleep to them.

Something i love to listen to at my job, takes stories that would be sickening for me to read and makes them a little funny. the dynamic between hunter and isaiah is great

It was 3 in the morning. I was listening to Wendigoon speaking his beautiful words out of his big meaty lips, and all of a sudden a man in a mobility scooter shot my dog who was downstairs in his cage. 10/10 would creep my cast to Hunter and Wendi’s voices!!!!😩😩😩

Love the bros. Best dynamic. Exactly like me and the guy who introduced me to them via indoctrination

When I listen to this podcast while working or doing chores time passes so fast, whatever story they are reading my mind just wonders off and next thing you know 3 hours pass. Totally love this podcast.

Hi Wendy and Hunty, Wendy said my irl name but it’s spelled differently so it’s funny to me and I laughed. STAY CREEPING UP YOUR CAST WENDY AND HUNTY!!!!

Papameat has always been a great means of entertainment and wendigoon compliments the dynamic so well! 10/10 worth listening to

Sometimes spooky, always fun

Hunter’s grandpa killed my hunting dog, I heard a mobility scooter, he had a deer rifle.

I have been listening since the original Barrasca episode came out and just fell in love with the narration, the voice acting, the laughter, literally every part. this podcast has a home-y feel to it now and i’ll never stop listening. every week we go on a new adventure and I always feel like i’m transported into the story. Isaiah and Hunter have been my favorites individually and together they are even better. Please never stop!!!